The Play Is Under Evaluate: A Look At The NHL’s Department Of Player Safety

Picture by way of

The Nationwide Hockey League’s Department of Player Safety is the division charged with reviewing on-ice infractions, assessing supplemental self-discipline, and educating gamers on what is taken into account unsafe in an effort to decrease the danger of damage throughout a recreation.

Previous to the formation of the Department of Player Safety (DoPS) in 2011, supplemental self-discipline for on-ice infractions was dealt with by Hockey Operations. Groups would mail the NHL’s then-Government Vice President and Director of Hockey Operations Brian Burke VHS tapes of incidents they felt ought to be reviewed. When Damian Echevarrieta, present Vice President of Player Safety and Hockey Operations, got here to the NHL in 1999, he assembled a makeshift room with various televisions and VCRs to document video games. At the conclusion of these video games, staffers have been capable of evaluate any incidents from the night time. Any incidents can be despatched from the NHL’s New York workplaces to the workplaces in Toronto for Burke’s successor, Colin Campbell, to evaluation. In describing the primary iteration of the DoPS, Echevarrieta stated: “my first yr, we rigged a satellite tv for pc dish in a nook convention room mentioning the window of the forty sixth flooring and ran wires by means of the ceiling to our makeshift video room.”

In 2011, the NHL separated participant security from Hockey Operations and created the Department of Player Safety. Commissioner Gary Bettman introduced the institution of the DoPS saying, “I’m creating efficient after this season a brand new Department of Player Safety which might be headed by Senior Vice President of Player Safety and Hockey Operations, Brendan Shanahan. On this revised position, Brendan shall be answerable for creating guidelines associated to raised defending our gamers with out altering the elemental nature of our recreation, coping with gear and questions of safety associated to gear, and pursuant to a request made by Colin Campbell, Brendan will administer commissioner supplemental self-discipline.”


. . . . .

The DoPS is predicated out of the twelfth flooring of the NHL’s workplaces in New York. The room the place Player Safety is stationed options twelve excessive-definition televisions, together with workstations that each one collectively make the most of ten screens. On these screens, the house and away feeds of each broadcast are streamed reside. Each broadcasts are seen to restrict bias from both broadcast’s commentators. At current, this workplace consists of Senior Vice President of Player Safety Stephane Quintal, Vice President of Player Safety Damian Echevarrieta, Director of Player Safety Patrick Burke, supervisor Evan Rand, and coordinators Michael Grover, Peter Livera, Chris Nastro, and Paul Treyman. Former NHL participant Chris Pronger critiques for the DoPS from his house in St. Louis. Corridor of Famer Pat LaFontaine advises unofficially for the DoPS as properly.

Within the DoPS workplace, not solely are incidents which will require supplemental self-discipline reported, however unintentional and clear collisions as nicely. Additionally famous are whether or not a group’s broadcast precisely identifies guidelines to make sure followers are receiving the right info. All collectively, greater than 800 clips have been reviewed through the 2011-2012 season.

Key elements thought-about when analyzing a questionable play that would end in a suspension from the NHL’s Department of Player Safety are: what occurred on this specific occasion, whether or not or not an damage resulted, the supplemental self-discipline historical past of the participant, and when the participant in query’s group performs subsequent.


Patrick Burke defined how repeat offenders are assessed when figuring out supplemental self-discipline: “We have now a way of, ‘Are you doing the identical issues time and again? Are you studying from what we’re making an attempt to inform you?’ In case you have a borderline boarding suspension, and then you definitely come again three years later, you’ve by no means been suspended once more, and you’ve got a borderline, no matter, rule forty eight suspension, they’re very totally different performs. It’s not ‘Oh, this man isn’t getting it.’ So a big portion of what we do right here is making an attempt to vary participant conduct. Making an attempt to be proactive, attain out to guys, and, if we really feel a participant isn’t studying from what we’re making an attempt to show him, then, yeah, we’ll hit him more durable.”

What penalties, if any, have been assessed on the ice are additionally factored into the choice-making course of. On the penalties referred to as on these infractions, Echevarrieta stated: “[no matter what the decision is on the ice, we take a look at each play by itself benefit, regardless of if there was a penalty referred to as on the ice or not.”

The DoPS should take a look at whether or not an damage resulted from the play in query, as a result of the CBA mandates that this be a consideration in figuring out supplemental self-discipline. Nevertheless, an damage doesn’t decide whether or not or not a participant is suspended. Shanahan defined: “I had a participant who requested me, ‘If I hit a man clear, however he will get harm and I’ve a historical past, am I gonna get suspended?’ And I stated ‘no.’ The presence of an damage doesn’t make a authorized hit unlawful. Nevertheless, if there’s an unlawful hit, the shortage of damage won’t exonerate you. However the presence of an damage will get you extra video games.” One other DoPS-associated notice within the CBA is a rule barring groups and common managers from contacting the DoPS to foyer or complain about an incident till forty eight hours after the infraction.

Additionally thought-about is whether or not the gamers concerned have any prior historical past that type a story that signifies further self-discipline is important. The context might help the DoPS perceive the motive of the participant who commits the act. Comparable situations are additionally checked out for comparability, so DoPS is ready to comply with its personal precedents and keep consistency.

All reviewable incidents are entered into software program that clips the printed, permitting the play to be reviewed body-by-body. Every play that’s clipped is reviewed by the DoPS. With this software program, it may be decided to a tenth of a second how lengthy after a participant releases the puck that a hit takes place (the NHL defines a late hit whether it is zero.6 to zero.7 seconds after a participant doesn’t have the puck). By reviewing footage body-by-body, the DoPS can see the primary level of contact throughout a collision inside a fraction of an inch.

That footage is shipped by way of e-mail to the members of the DoPS, with all suggestions being despatched again to Quintal. Quintal requires that these analyzing ship him an e mail again with out replying to all partaking within the choice to make sure unbiased judgements. After everybody submits their opinions all these concerned debate to return to a last determination. Quintal has the ultimate say over the self-discipline after listening to the issues raised by these concerned within the choice making course of. Selections can vary from a warning to a high-quality, listening to (which possible would end in a suspension), or no motion.

As soon as the DoPS determines whether or not or to not self-discipline a participant for an incident, a video is revealed by the NHL with an evidence of the choice. Commissioner Bettman launched these movies when Shanahan took over the Department. These movies clarify precisely the place a play went incorrect in an effort to teach the gamers and followers, in addition to maintain the participant in query accountable for his or her actions.

The NHL and DoPS intend to be as clear as potential with the groups, gamers, and followers, and these movies present one of the best alternative for the DoPS to take action. “Once we’re on the fence a few play, we’ll typically say, ‘Can we make a video explaining why we’re suspending this man?’ And if the reply is not any, then we don’t droop. To have to truly show with the video, with the cash shot, with the precise spot shadow, with the precise guidelines, it actually retains us trustworthy and according to previous rulings,” Echevarrieta defined.

. . . . .

Supplementary self-discipline is much less frequent within the Stanley Cup Playoffs than the common season, as playoff video games are seen as extra important. A suspension that may happen within the playoffs sometimes is shorter than the identical suspension can be had it occurred within the common season––one playoff recreation is usually equal to 3 common season video games. The DoPS needed to act twice within the second spherical of the 2016 Stanley Cup Playoffs, within the collection between the Washington Capitals and Pittsburgh Penguins.

First, Capitals’ defenseman Brooks Orpik was suspended three video games for a late hit to the top of defenseman Olli Maatta of the Penguins. Burke, who narrated the NHL’s video explaining the suspension, said: “this hit is forceful, unacceptably excessive and excessively late,” including that “no participant ought to fairly anticipate to be hit right now and on this method.” Additionally thought-about within the choice to droop was the truth that Maatta left the sport after the hit and didn’t return to the sport. Moreover, Orpik has been suspended twice in his profession previous to this occasion, though he has not been suspended since the 2005-06 season. Orpik initially solely acquired a two minute minor for interference for the hit on Maatta.Orpik_zpsmfdyidoe

Orpik acknowledged his wrongdoing after the suspension was introduced, saying “it was meant to be a tough hit, undoubtedly not at his head however I don’t assume there’s something you can argue that it was undoubtedly late. I feel that was fairly black and white. I stated that in my listening to yesterday. So, I’m simply disenchanted. It’s a cut up-second determination you make and I simply gotta reside with it.”

The subsequent recreation, Penguins’ defenseman Kris Letang hit Marcus Johansson, and was penalized on the ice with a minor for interference. Letang’s hit resulted in a one recreation suspension being handed down by the DoPS. In contrast to in Orpik’s case, Johansson was not injured on the play, although he briefly left the sport after hit.

One other main distinction between the incidents was the lateness of the hits. Each hits have been thought-about to be late; Letang’s hit got here zero.sixty three seconds after Johansson launched the puck whereas Orpik hit Maatta a full second after he took a shot, which is “excessively late” in response to the NHL. Had Letang’s hit been thought-about charging, he would have seen harsher self-discipline. Nevertheless, the DoPS attributed Letang leaving his ft through the hit to the drive of the collision. Moreover, the top was not the “fundamental level of contact.” As an alternative, the infraction was solely thought-about to be interference.

Whereas many seen the infractions as comparable since each did hit the top of the opposing participant and each noticed an interference minor on the ice, the distinction in damage and lateness have been the distinguishing elements. Letang’s prior historical past with the DoPS was not for interference, quite it was for a unique sort of infraction. Thus, it didn’t influence the self-discipline as a lot as it might have had it been for a similar infraction.

. . . . .

The DoPS is trying to do extra than simply punish unfavorable performs, however to vary the conduct and tradition of the sport. Subsequently, it’s crucial that the DoPS educate gamers on what’s suspendable, which is why gamers who will not be suspended however did one thing questionable are sometimes warned and are made to know the ramifications of most of these infractions.

Shanahan noticed the potential for the DoPS to vary the tradition of the NHL by penalizing unsafe performs, however he additionally acknowledged that the method would take time. “We perceive that if you’re making an attempt to make an enormous change in a recreation during which issues have been achieved a sure method for a very long time and there are continuously new gamers coming in, I feel that it takes some time.”

Many really feel that DoPS is affected by inconsistency. Followers typically level to the DoPS video library to implicate the DoPS for being inconsistent. For instance, some followers have been upset over the discrepancy in Orpik’s and Letang’s suspensions, since each have been suspended for an interference penalty. Nevertheless, these situations have been actually totally different beneath the NHL’s guidelines, however that’s typically ignored by followers who’re unhappy by DoPS’s choice. The various to the present course of can be the imposition of a uniform suspension, which might get rid of the consideration of context of the incident.

Whereas the league may have to extend its efforts to alleviate considerations relating to inconsistency, altering the system in favor of a uniform suspension mannequin can be problematic since most situations are distinctive. Contemplating the narrative is necessary as a result of gamers might have been trying to injure somebody on the opposing staff, and deliberate the incident prematurely.

Prior historical past is essential as a result of it may possibly assist point out whether or not a participant has discovered from his previous infractions. And the precise mechanisms of a play are crucial to take a look at, as a result of the slightest motion can change what rule is damaged. The DoPS is probably not completely constant, however earlier than making that judgement the principles have to be absolutely understood, and the options to a versatile disciplinary scale have to be absolutely thought-about.

No fan can be utterly glad with the DoPS due to the consequences of league self-discipline on their staff, however that isn’t why the division is in place; moderately, it exists to guard the gamers on the ice by penalizing those that put different gamers in danger and educating gamers on find out how to conduct themselves on the ice.

As Echevarrieta stated, “It’s the Department of Player Safety, not the division of punishment. We’re making an attempt to vary their conduct. Our good season wouldn’t be 100 suspensions, the place we present everyone we’re in cost. It might be no suspensions, the place gamers aren’t breaking any guidelines.”