The Yankees are overrated, the Cubs are lost and other MLB early season hot takes

Joe-Maddon-Stanton-Judge-SPLIT-FTR-041718
(Getty Pictures)

Baseball is a sport that lends itself to overreactions, each in the constructive and unfavorable. Identical to evaluations of a brand new “Star Wars” film.

Frankly, it is arduous not to attract conclusions from the early season goings-on in Main League Baseball. In any case, it is a lengthy season and individuals nonetheless aren’t fairly positive once they’re allowed to type arguments and panic over their workforce’s lack of success. So let’s simply take it to the excessive.

Placed on your oven mitts, as a result of you are going to want them to deal with these hearth takes.

(Man, do I really feel sleazy. I am sorry prematurely.)

Loosen up, Shohei Ohtani is not the actual deal

I’ll out myself right here and be one hundred % trustworthy: I simply wasn’t positive that Shohei Ohtani was going to succeed at the main-league degree. At the very least, not at this degree. That stated, his success will not final. Like the man from Males’s Wearhouse, I assure it.

Clearly, he earned the hype in Japan and that adopted him over to the U.S. It is troublesome to throw away the stats and accolades Ohtani earned whereas abroad, however success abroad does not all the time translate to MLB, particularly this shortly. It is largely unseen.

Simply keep in mind, for each Masahiro Tanaka and Yu Darvish, there is a Daisuke Matsuzaka and Kaz Matsui. 

The true shock right here is Ohtani’s dominance on the mound and in the hitter’s field. Ohtani’s posted a 2.08 ERA (1.seventy five FIP — hearth emojis right here) and a zero.462 WHIP in thirteen innings pitched, and he is matched that at the plate: In 30 at-bats, he is put up a .367 common with three bombs and a 1.191 OPS. Ask your self this query: Do you actually consider that is sustainable?

FOSTER: Properly, on the other hand…

In any case, his two begins got here towards the second-to-final place A’s. His first actual check comes Tuesday towards the Pink Sox, so we’ll see. 

This type of success on each side of the ball is just not solely extraordinary, however it’s unimaginable over a 162-recreation season. Is Ohtani good at baseball? Perhaps. However is he traditionally good? Completely not. Sooner or later, he will hit the wall like the aspect of a tree on the forest moon of Endor.

See via the smoke and mirrors. This would possibly not final. You already know it. I do know it.

That is what the Cubs are — settle for it

Whereas we’re lower than two years faraway from the Cubs ending their World Collection drought, it is beginning to really feel prefer it’s been 108 years.

Whereas 2017’s early season woes might be attributed — and even forgiven — to a World Collection victory hangover, the Cubs have accomplished nothing to reply questions that have to be answered early in 2018. Their rotation is dangerous; solely Kyle Hendricks has a sub-four.forty ERA. In the meantime, Yu Darvish hasn’t been good, pitching to a 6.00 ERA (5.19 FIP), including one other query mark to the employees. Can Darvish determine it out over the subsequent 5 months? I am unsure. Simply does not look like sufficient time.

Kyle Schwarber put up 30 bombs final yr and someway managed to place up a zero.zero bWAR and an OPS+ of ninety eight in 2017. Whereas he is off to a greater begin in 2018, the jury continues to be out on him. Does anyone actually know what Kyle Schwarber is as a ballplayer?

It is a good factor the Cubs had an incredible end in 2017, going forty nine-25 in the second half and lastly wanting like the workforce they have been imagined to be for the subsequent decade. If not, followers can be calling for heads to roll and begging for trades (if we’re not there already).

That is it — the finish of the Cubs “dynasty,” and it is going out with a much bigger thud than the newest Nickelback album. In the event that they maintain this up, they might be sellers at the deadline.

The Yankees are extraordinarily overrated

Placing up 12 runs towards the Marlins is like profitable a recreation of Scrabble towards a new child. Sorry, Marlins. Everybody is aware of that is what you are. It is OK. It’s going to all be over quickly.

And for my subsequent trick, I’ll solely discredit what the Yankees are this yr.

Giancarlo Stanton has accomplished nothing up to now in pinstripes: Two of his three residence runs got here on Opening Day and he hasn’t hit since. He has 25 strikeouts in fifty nine at-bats and a sub-.800 OPS. Assume the Yankees remorse the commerce but? We’re already into mid-April, so some massive-time doubts are beginning to float round as as to if he’ll have the ability to determine it out this season. Not like his resume is that beautiful, both.

FAGAN: Giancarlo Stanton on an inventory he does not need to be on

Then there’s the “biggest bullpen of all time,” which could not cease a Little League workforce from scoring a run proper now. Throw out the incontrovertible fact that it was amongst the greatest bullpens in MLB final season — although 4 of their relievers at present rank inside the prime 25 in MLB in common velocity.

Then there’s supervisor Aaron Boone, who Yankees followers already need gone, and with good purpose: He is steered them to an eight-7 report after 2 half weeks of play. A .500 report over that span undoubtedly has by no means, ever occurred in the historical past of Yankees championship-profitable seasons. Undoubtedly not. Do not even give it some thought. It has by no means occurred. … Ever.

Time is operating out in the Yankees’ season to have the ability to determine this all out — 147 video games simply will not be sufficient.

The Mets will not have the ability to get well

The Mets have been in all probability feeling rather a lot like Marv in “House Alone 2” — they’ve reached the prime. Now, it appears like they will fall right into a pit identical to Marv did.

Very similar to Macaulay in that second installment, the Amazins’ are about to be lost in New York. Their franchise-greatest begin might be flushed down the rest room, as their newest loss — an eight-6 loss to the Nationals after blowing a 6-1 eighth-inning lead — will set them on an irreversible course, one which they will be unable to determine over the subsequent 5-plus months’ value of video games. They could by no means win once more, if we’re being trustworthy.

The query surrounding the Mets has by no means been the expertise, however the well being of the group. And till they show they will keep wholesome — one thing they’ve struggled with early in the season — they can not be taken critically as a contender. Document be damned. Dominance of division opponents extra so.

Does it actually matter that their 5 Ace rotation is performing as much as considerably lofty expectations? No. As a result of these are the Mets, and everybody is aware of that Citi Area was constructed on a sacred burial floor, so they are going to be cursed perpetually.

The Astros will crash again to actuality

If Astros followers have not heard this track earlier than, perhaps they need to: It is about to play on a loop.

It is becoming that the Minute Maid Park roof was open Sunday night time so Astros followers might get a great take a look at the sky falling in Houston. Bartolo Colon almost pitched an ideal recreation, silencing the daunting Astros’ offense en path to a three-1 Rangers win.

Then, on Monday, the Astros scored a single run towards the second-place Mariners, dropping 2-1. That is proper: the second-place Mariners. If that is not an indication of the finish occasions, I am unsure what’s.

The World Collection hangover is reliable. The Astros, four-6 of their previous 10, will hover round .500 the remainder of the yr, as their lineup beneath-performs. Lately acquired rotation stud Gerrit Cole will come crashing again right down to Earth with the remainder of the staff.

Their offense — at present center of the pack in the American League — has no shot to rebound this season, even with reigning AL MVP Jose Altuve and World Collection MVP George Springer. Why even hassle displaying as much as the ballpark?